情绪介入经济决策研究的演变路径——从古典经济学到神经经济学An Evolutionary Route of Economic Decision-making Studies with the Introduction of Emotion:From Classical Economics to Neuroeconomics
卿志琼;
摘要(Abstract):
情绪曾是古典经济学研究经济决策的出发点。新古典经济学的理性决策模型却把情绪视为干扰因素而加以排除。行为经济学从有限理性、偏好逆转和认知偏差中"发现"了情绪对经济决策的重要影响。神经经济学则运用fMRI等脑成像技术揭示了情绪影响经济决策的脑神经机制。文章从经济学的发展过程探讨情绪影响经济决策的演变路径,试图运用不同分析视角形成情绪与决策关系的一般分析框架及其适用条件。最后探讨了情绪与决策关系研究的未来发展方向。
关键词(KeyWords): 情绪;经济决策;古典经济学;神经经济学
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金资助项目(08BJY001)
作者(Author): 卿志琼;
Email:
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2009.09.001
参考文献(References):
- [2]Roberta Muramatsu,Yaniv Hanoch.Emotions as a Mechanismfor Boundedly Rational A-gents:The Fast and Frugal Way,Journal of Economic Psychology,2005,26:201-221.
- [3]汪丁丁、罗卫东、叶航:《人类合作秩序的起源与演化》,《社会科学战线》,2005年第4期,第40页。
- [4]张辉华、凌文辁:《理性、情绪与个体经济决策》,《外国经济与管理》,2005年第5期,第2-9页。
- [5]亚当.斯密:《道德情操论》,商务印书馆1997年版,第5页。
- [6]杨春学:《经济人与社会秩序分析》,上海三联书店、上海人民出版社1998年版,第144-164页。
- [7]Kauf man B E.Emotional Arousal as a Source of Bouned Rationalty,Journal of Economic Behavior&Organization,1999,38:135-144.
- [8]Slovic P,Finucane M,Peters E,et al.The Affect Heuristic,Gilovich T,Griffin D,Kahe-man D(eds.).Heuristics and Biases:The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment,Cambridge University Press,2002:397-420.
- [9]Kahneman D,Tversky A.The Psychology of Preferences,Scientific’American,1982,246:136-142.
- [10]Kahneman D,I Ritow,D Schkade.Economic Preferences or Attitude Expressions-Jour-nal of Risk and Uncertainty,1999,19:203-235.
- 11G Loomes,R Sugden.Regret Theory:An Alternative Theory of Rational Choice under Uncertainty,Economic Journal,1982,92:805-824.
- 12Shefrin H,MStat man.The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long:Theory and Evidence,Journal of Finance,1985,40:777-790.
- 13Gul F.A Theory of Disappoint ment Aversion,Econometrica,1991,59:667-686.
- 14Ackert Lucy F,Charupat Narat,Church Bryan K,et al.Bubbles in Experimental Asset Markets:Irrational Exuberance no More,Federal Reserve Bank of Atlantal Working Pa-per,2002-24.
- 15David Sally.On Sympathy and Games,Journal of Economic Behavior&Organization,2001,44:1-30.
- 16Hsu M,Bhatt M,Adolphs R,et al.Neural Systems Responding to Degrees of Uncertainty in Human Decision-making,Science,2005,310:1680-1683.
- 17McClure S M,Laibson DI,Loewenstein G,et al.Separate Neural Systems Value Immedi-ate and Delayed Monetary Rewards,Science,2004,306:503-507.
- 18Knutson B,Rick S,Wimmer G E,et al.Neural Predictors of Purchases,Neuron,2007,53(1):147-156.
- 19Kuhnen C M,Knutson B.The Neural Basis of Financial Risk Taking,Neuron,2005,47:763-770.
- 20Steven Schultz.Brain Imaging Study Reveals Interplay of Thought and Emotion in Eco-nomic Decisions,Princeton Weekly Bulletin,2003,93(12):12-18.
- 21Sanfey A G,Rilling J K,Aronson J A,et al.The Neural Basis of Economic Decision-Mak-ing in the Ultimatum Game,Science,2003,300:1755-1758.
- 22Coricelli G,Critchley H D,Joffily M,et al.Regret and Its Avoidance:A Neuroimaging Study of Choice Behavior,Nat Neurosci,2005,8:1255-1262.
- 23Taylor J G,Fragopanagos N F.The Interaction of Attention and Emotion,Emotion,2005,(18):353-369.
- 24乔纳森.默瑟:《人性与第一意象:国际政治中的情绪》,《世界经济与政治》,2006年第12期,第46-54页。
- 25Kauf man B E.Emotional Arousal as a Source of Bounded Rationality,Journal of Eco-nomic Behavior&Organization,1999,38:135-144.
- 26Bernard J Baars,Nicole MGage:《认知、脑与意识——认知神经科学导论》,科学出版社2008年版,第376-377页。
- 27Bechara A.Risky Business:Emotion,Decision-Making,and Addiction,Journal of Gam-bling Studies,2003,19(1):23-51.
- 28安东尼奥.R.达马西奥:《笛卡尔的错误——情绪、推理与人脑》,教育科学出版社2007年版,第2页。
- 29刘恒超、许燕:《情绪研究的新趋向:从有意识情绪到无意识情绪》,《北京师范大学学报》(社会科学版),2008年第6期,第43-50页。
- [1]科林.凯莫勒.行为博弈——对策论互动的实验研究[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006.
- [2]郭旭新.有限理性与情绪的经济学分析[J].经济学动态,2003,(3):62-64.
- [3]卿志琼.有限理性、心智成本与经济秩序[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2006.
- [4]Fehr Ernst,Klaus MSchmidt.Atheory of fairness,competition and cooperation[J].Quarter-ly Journal of Economics,1999,114,817-868.
- [2]Finucane M L,Peters E,Slovic P.Judgment and decision making:The dance of affect and reason[A].Schneider S L,Shanteau J.Emerging perspectives on judgment and de-cision research[C].Cambridge University Press,2003:287-326.