管制经济学的演进——从传统理论到比较制度分析The Development of Regulation Economics Analyses:From Traditional Theory to Comparative Institution
曹啸;计小青;
摘要(Abstract):
文章梳理了管制经济学从传统理论到比较制度分析的演进逻辑,并指出传统的管制理论采取的是把市场和政府对立起来的二分分析方法,而新的管制理论则采取了一种把市场和政府统一起来的分析方法,这种理论进展有助于我们更加深刻地认识现实世界中的管制制度。
关键词(KeyWords): 市场;政府;公共利益理论;利益集团理论;比较制度分析
基金项目(Foundation): 上海财经大学211工程项目;; 上海财经大学现代金融研究中心课题资助
作者(Author): 曹啸;计小青;
Email:
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2006.10.007
参考文献(References):
- ③参见Voigt,s和Engerer,H(2002,中文版2004)。
- [1]青木昌彦.比较制度分析[M].上海:上海远东出版社,2001.
- [2]张杰.究竟是什么决定一国银行制度的选择——重新解读中国国有银行改革的含义[J].金融研究,2005,(9):5~22.
- [3]Shleifer A.理解监管[A].吴敬琏.比较(第16辑)[C].北京:中信出版社,2005.
- [4]Bickenbach F,Kumkar L,Soltwedel R.反托拉斯和管制[A].齐默尔曼.经济学前沿问题[C].北京:中国发展出版社,2004.
- [5]Voigt S,Engerer H.制度和转型[A].齐默尔曼.经济学前沿问题[C].北京:中国发展出版社,2004.
- [6]Becker G S.Atheory of competition among pressure groups for political influence[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1983,(3):371~400.
- [7]Becker G S.The public interest hypothesis revisited:Newtest of peltzman’s theory of regulation[J].Public Choice,1986,49(3):223~234.
- [8]Djankov E,Glaeser E L,Rafacl La Porta A.The newcomparative economics[J].Jour-nal of Comparative Economics,2003,(12):595~619.
- [9]Joskow P L,Noll R G.Regulation in theory and practice:An overview[A].Gray Fromm.Studies in public regulation[C].MIT Press1981:1~65.
- [10]McChesney,Fred S.Rent extraction and rent creationin the economic theory of regu-lation[J].Journal of Legal Studies,1987,16:101~118.
- [11]Peltzman S.Toward a more general theory of regulation[J].Journal of Lawand Eco-nomics,1976,19(2):211~240.
- [12]Pigou A.The economics of welfare[M].London:Mac Millan,1938.
- [13]Pistor K,Xu Chenggang.Incomplete law:A conceptual and analytical framework and its application to the evolution of financial market regulation[EB/OL].Working paper,http://www.ssrn.com,2005-05.
- [14]Posner R.Theories of economic regulation[J].Bell Journal of Economic Management,1974,(5):335~358.
- [15]Stigler GJ.The theory of economic regulation[J].Bell Journal of Economics and Man-agement Science,1977,(2):3~21.
- [16]Trebing H M.Regulation of industry:Aninstitutionalist approach[J].Journal of Eco-nomic Issues,1987,(4):1707~1737